How to improve AI business efficiency | Case studies and 7 steps to implement
Improving business efficiency through AI is an initiative that not only reduces work, but also allows free time to be used for customer service and analysis, and measures business results. First, select one repetitive task where a person can check the correct answer, and compare the processing time and quality before and after introduction.
| Tasks to try first | Parts to be left to AI | Parts to be checked by humans | Indicators to measure effectiveness |
|---|---|---|---|
| Records of meetings and business negotiations | Summary and organization of decisions | Proper noun, deadline, person in charge | Record creation time, number of revisions |
| Inquiry response | Classification of content and proposed answers | Basis, contract terms, and content | Initial response time, return rate |
| Invoice processing | Reading of items and transcription proposals | Verification with original documents, payment approval | Input time, number of misread items |
We will explain usage examples by department, how to select target operations, and 7 steps for implementation.
Last updated: 2026-11-07
Review conditions: When product specifications, contract conditions, business rules, or related laws and regulations are changed.
Conclusion|What is business efficiency improvement through AI?
Increasing work efficiency through AI is an effort to reallocate employee time to high-value-added work by automating routine tasks, as well as document creation, information classification, prediction, and decision support. The targets are information processing and repetitive operations. In order for the implementation to be successful, it is essential to first decide who will be responsible for checking business KPIs and results, and not to make the introduction of AI an end in itself.
Utilization methods can be divided into automation, support, and optimization. The results include not only the reduction in work time, but also what work the free time was allocated to and what changed there.
What is automation by AI? Difference from support and optimization
Automation using AI is a system in which AI takes charge of document classification, content generation, prediction, anomaly detection, etc., reducing the repetitive processing and judgment preparation required by humans.
| Classification | Role | Human involvement |
|---|---|---|
| Automation | Delegate work and operations | Responsible for exception handling and approval |
| Support | Present sentences and judgment candidates | Select and confirm content |
| Optimization | Improve allocation and planning from data | Decide on constraints and adoption |
Main benefits of AI business efficiency
The value of AI operational efficiency lies not only in reducing work time, but also in reducing rework, speeding up responses, and freeing up employee time for customer support and analysis.
-
Reduce the amount of work time spent on transcription and aggregation.
-
You can prevent input errors and sendbacks.
-
Speed up the initial response to inquiries.
-
Share knowledge that only those in charge have.
-
Accumulated data can be used for classification and prediction.
-
You can redeploy people to suggestions, education, and quality improvement.
The evaluation target is not the number of features introduced. Compare processing time, quality, response speed, etc. before and after implementation.
Reason: In a 2025 survey by JIPDEC and ITR, among companies that use generative AI company-wide or in specific departments, 45.2% answered that it was "very effective" and 38.8% said it was "somewhat effective" in improving the efficiency of daily operations.
Reason | How AI is effective for business improvement
AI can share text creation, summarization, classification, search, prediction, input processing, and workflow execution, making both information processing and routine operations more efficient.
However, if you apply AI to inefficient processes, even unnecessary processes will be sped up. It is important to consider eliminating, merging, or reordering processes first.
What are the four principles of business improvement?
The four principles of business improvement are elimination'' to eliminate unnecessary tasks, combining'' to combine processes, exchange'' to change the order and responsibilities, and simplification'' to make tasks easier to understand.
-
Elimination: Eliminate input, approvals, and materials that do not contribute to results.
-
Merge: Combine duplicate confirmations and postings into one process.
-
Exchange: Change the processing order, person in charge, and location.
-
Simplification: Standardize input items and judgment rules.
Apply this ECRS and assign AI to the remaining work.
Reallocation design that connects reduced time to business results
The time saved by AI is not the result itself but surplus capacity, and the value of operational efficiency can only be evaluated after deciding where to reallocate it and business KPIs.
| Operations targeted for reduction | Spare capacity created | Reallocation destination | Results KPI |
|---|---|---|---|
| Creating minutes | Recording and formatting time | Additional proposals to customers | Number of proposals, conversion rate |
| Inquiry classification | Sorting time | Handling difficult consultations | First resolution rate, satisfaction level |
| Invoice entry | Posting and reconciliation time | Variance analysis, cash management | Reversal rate, closing days |
| Search for internal materials | Search time | Education, quality improvement | Proficiency level, rework rate |
Reason: According to a survey by Persol Research Institute, the work time for tasks using generative AI was reduced by an average of 16.7%, or 26.4 minutes per week, while only about 25% of users saw a decrease in work time.
What AI can and cannot make more efficient
AI is suitable for work where correct answer conditions can be defined, data is available, and results can be checked by humans. Human involvement is required for responsible final decisions and tasks that cannot be verified.
| Operations | Efficiency examples | Application conditions |
|---|---|---|
| Writing texts | Drafting emails and reports | People can check facts and expressions |
| Summary | Organizing meetings and inquiries | You can refer to the original text |
| Classification | Sorting matters and documents | Classification criteria are clear |
| Search | Suggestions for internal regulations | Manage reference scope and update date |
| Forecasting | Forecasting demand and signs of failure | High-quality historical data available |
| Input processing | Reading and posting of forms | Can check misreading |
| Execution | Registration, notification, distribution | Limit authority and termination methods |
| High-impact judgment | Up to organizing candidates and evidence | Approver makes final decision |
5 conditions for work that can be easily made more efficient with AI
When introducing AI, the first job to choose is one that requires a large amount of work, has few exceptions, allows humans to confirm correct answers, and can be measured using the same indicators before and after the introduction.
-
There is a large amount of work, and we can expect to see results when improvements are made.
-
Processing methods are standardized and judgment criteria are clear.
-
Check the quality and permissions of available data.
-
The impact of errors is small and can be corrected by humans.
-
Fewer exceptions, processing time and quality can be measured.
Operations that do not leave final decisions to AI
For work that has a large impact, such as legal affairs, accounting, personnel evaluation, and safety management, it is basic to incorporate evidence checking and approvers into the work flow, rather than relying on AI to make the final decision.
| Business | Role of AI | Person responsible for checking |
|---|---|---|
| Contracts/Legal Affairs | Organizing clause candidates and points of contention | Legal personnel, authority |
| Accounting entries | Suggestions for account items | Accounting person, approver |
| Personnel evaluation/recruitment | Record organization and perspective presentation | Evaluator, hiring manager |
| External transmission | Draft text | Sender, public relations manager |
| Medical/safety judgment | Information organization and warning | Qualified person, safety officer |
This design is called human-in-the-loop.
Differences between generation AI, RPA, AI-OCR, and AI agent
Generative AI is suitable for non-routine tasks such as writing, summarizing, and categorizing, RPA is suitable for operating fixed procedures, AI-OCR is suitable for extracting characters and items from forms and images, and AI agents are suitable for processing that spans multiple processes and tools. If you divide your work into ``what to read, what to judge, and what to execute,'' it will be easier to choose the methods to introduce.
Generative AI, RPA, AI-OCR, and AI agents are means of improving business efficiency, each with different processes that they are good at. Rather than looking for something to replace individually, combine each process of existing business.
By separating the input, judgment, generation, execution, and approval of operations and selecting corresponding technologies, you can clarify the process where the error occurred and the responsibility for confirmation.
RPA is not necessarily AI. However, you can receive the output of generated AI and AI-OCR and operate the business system. For example, it is possible to collaborate by extracting invoice items using AI-OCR, collating them using rules, and then inputting them into an accounting system using RPA.
Comparison table for different uses of AI methods
We assign generation AI to processes that handle texts and meanings, RPA to perform predetermined operations, AI-OCR to read forms, machine learning to predict, and AI agents to execute multiple processes. The number of exceptions, the importance of the information handled, and the presence or absence of execution authority are also items to check when making a selection.
RPA is suitable for tasks where judgment criteria are fixed and operating procedures do not change, while generative AI is suitable for tasks that require interpretation and documentation of the content.
| Means | Suitable tasks | Unsuitable tasks | Confirmation of people | Difficulty of implementation | Main risks |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Generative AI | Creation, summary, classification | Strict fact determination | Required in principle | Low to medium | Misinformation, information leaks |
| RPA | Routine operations, transcription | Screen changes and exceptions | Required for exceptions | Medium | Incorrect execution, maintenance burden |
| AI-OCR | Reading of forms | Unclear image | Verification required | Medium | Misreading, misaligned items |
| Predictive AI | Forecasting demand and abnormalities | Events without history | Requires hiring decision | Medium to high | Data bias |
| AI agent | Execution of multiple processes | Processing with ambiguous scope of responsibility | Approval gate required | High | Deviation of authority, chain error |
-
If you mainly draft documents, organize and classify inquiries: Generating AI
-
When repeatedly inputting and posting the same item on the same screen: RPA
-
When acquiring characters/items from paper forms, PDFs, and images: AI-OCR
-
When determining trends in demand and abnormalities based on past data: Predictive AI
-
When connecting multiple processes from information collection to tool operation and result confirmation: AI agent
Business design divided by input, judgment, generation, execution, and approval
In order to improve AI business efficiency, we do not rely on a single tool to handle the entire process, but instead design the process by breaking it down into input, judgment, generation, execution, and approval. By determining the technology to be used, confirmation method, and responsible person for each process, it is possible to determine where to stop processing and who to respond when an exception occurs.
It is important to have approval procedures in processes where errors can have a large impact, such as registration in external systems and payment confirmation.
| Invoice processing process | Method | Processing details | Management method |
|---|---|---|---|
| Input | AI-OCR | Extract items from image | Match with original |
| Generation | Generation AI | Organize summary and content | Limit reference range |
| Judgment | Business rules | Verify amounts and business partners | Branch exceptions |
| Execution | RPA | Register in accounting system | Leave execution log |
| Approval | People | Finalize journal entries and payments | Authorized person approves |
-
Break down the target business into the steps of input, judgment, generation, execution, and approval.
-
For each step, check whether it is routine or atypical and where exceptions occur.
-
Assign methods such as AI-OCR for extraction, generation AI for content organization, and RPA for routine operations.
-
Set matching conditions, exception handling, and approvers for judgments and executions where errors have a large impact.
-
Keep a record of the operation details and exception handling so that you can check the execution results.
Difference between AI assistant and AI agent
The AI assistant is a system that returns answers and suggestions based on the user's instructions. On the other hand, an AI agent is a system that continuously searches, makes decisions, executes tools, and confirms results according to set goals.
A distinctive feature of AI assistants is that they are based on human operations.
AI agents are unique in that they span multiple processes.
AI assistants are suitable for tasks where the user gives instructions and confirms the content each time, while AI agents are suitable for tasks that require multiple steps to be performed according to predefined goals and procedures.
Generation AI and AI assistants are mainly responsible for content generation, and AI agents continuously search, judge, execute, and confirm according to the goal. Autonomy depends on the tools available, the authority granted, approvals, and oversight functions.
-
When a person creates a draft answer or sentence and selects and executes it: AI assistant
-
When checking multiple information sources and using different tools depending on conditions: AI agent
-
In cases involving system updates, external transmission, payments, etc.: Approval will be required before execution
-
If it is not possible to decide on the scope of responsibility or who will respond in case of exceptions: Limit to suggestion rather than autonomous execution
By department | Examples of AI business use
Utilizing AI in business operations is an effort to improve processing quality and speed by separating routine and decision-making tasks for each department and designing the roles of AI and humans.
When utilizing AI in business, it is important to divide the issues of each department into process units, combine generative AI, RPA, AI-OCR, and predictive AI, and set a person responsible for checking and KPIs. By deciding who will confirm and what to finalize in advance, it will be easier to incorporate AI output into work.
The targets for implementation should be selected from tasks for which processing procedures can be easily documented, such as input, search, summarization, classification, and draft creation. On the other hand, decisions that have a large impact, such as payment, acceptance/rejection, safety suspension, and whether or not to ship, require humans to make the final decision even if AI provides candidates.
-
Break down the work within the department into the processes of input, confirmation, judgment, registration, and reporting.
-
For each process, choose the appropriate method such as generative AI, RPA, AI-OCR, RAG, predictive AI, etc.
-
Decide who will be in charge of checking AI output, what items to check, and what to do in case of exceptions.
-
Review operations using KPIs that correspond to your business, such as creation time, input rate, remand rate, and primary resolution rate.
Sales and marketing usage examples
In the sales department, a practical flow is to use generation AI to create a summary of a deal or proposal, register it in CRM using RPA, and have a person in charge check customer information and external expressions.
Recording the details of business negotiations, drafting proposal emails, and organizing the structure of materials are areas where AI can easily take on the responsibility. Factual information such as customer name, contact person name, price, contract terms, actual values, etc. will be checked by the person in charge against the original information before submission/registration.
| Challenges | Target operations/AI methods | Confirmation of people | KPI candidates | Difficulty |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Recording burden | Business summary, CRM input | Numerical values, proper nouns | Creation time, input rate | Low to medium |
| Preparation of proposals | Generation of email and document structure | Facts, external expression | Number of proposals, rate of negotiations | Low |
| Policy analysis | Customer classification, analysis assistance | Population, interpretation | Response rate, rework rate | Medium |
-
Negotiation summaries can be output by dividing them into decisions, next actions, deadlines, and persons in charge.
-
For CRM registration, check to see if any required fields are left blank.
-
For customer classification and policy analysis, first define the target population and exclusion conditions.
Customer support usage examples
For customer support, a suitable configuration is where AI classifies inquiries, RAG searches internal information to create answer candidates, and the person in charge checks the rationale and wording.
RAG is a mechanism that searches for a specified document and passes its contents to the generation AI. The reference source and update date will be displayed in the answer.
The urgency of the inquiry, contract status, information regarding refunds and obstacles, etc. are not determined by the classification results alone; the person in charge will confirm the details. If the reference source cannot be found or the document is old, it is necessary to avoid sending the AI answer as is.
| Target operations | AI means | Confirmation | KPI candidates |
|---|---|---|---|
| Classification/Distribution | Classification AI, Workflow | Misclassification and Priority | Sorting Time |
| Answer candidates | RAG, generation AI | Evidence and up-to-dateness | Primary response time, primary resolution rate |
| Response summary | Generation AI | Missing important information | Post-processing time |
-
The name of the referenced document and the date of update are displayed in the answer candidates.
-
For answers regarding terms, fees, obstacles, and refunds, the person in charge will check the supporting documents and expressions.
-
In the response summary, record customer requests, guidance details, unresolved issues, and next response separately.
Utilization examples for accounting/finance, human resources/general affairs
For accounting, we will combine AI-OCR, generation AI, and RPA for each process, and for human resources, we will support document creation and response to inquiries, but humans will be responsible for final decisions regarding payment and hiring.
In accounting, by separating reading, verification, journal candidate creation, and registration, you can clarify what is being checked. In human resources and general affairs, it can be used to draft answers regarding job postings, training materials, and internal regulations, but decisions based on individual circumstances and interpretation of regulations are decided by the person in charge.
| Department | Target operations | AI methods | Matters determined by humans | KPI candidates |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Accounting | Invoice reading, verification, journal candidate, registration | AI-OCR, generation AI, RPA | Journal entry, payment | Input time, bounce rate |
| Human resources | Job postings, interview summaries, training materials | Generation AI | Recruitment/rejection, personnel evaluation | Creation time, confirmation time |
| General affairs | Internal inquiries | RAG, generative AI | Exception responses, regulation interpretation | First resolution rate |
-
When reading invoices, specify confirmation items such as customer name, amount, date, and tax classification.
-
Journal entry candidates are materials that refer to past processing, and are treated separately from finalization of accounting processing.
-
Interview summaries are used to organize the facts, and decisions regarding hiring or rejection or personnel evaluations are not left to AI.
Information system/development usage examples
In the information systems and development department, generated AI is used to draft code and tests, organize failure records, and create answer candidates for internal inquiries, while humans are responsible for reviews and security checks.
During development and operation, the output of AI is not directly reflected in the production environment, but a process is included to check consistency with specifications, test results, vulnerabilities, and licenses. The scope of input of authentication information and confidential information is also limited in advance.
-
Internal helpdesk searches for specifications in RAG.
-
For troubleshooting, assist with log classification and record summarization.
-
During development, we create drafts of code and test cases.
-
Generated code checks for vulnerabilities and licenses.
-
Restrict entry of credentials and sensitive information.
-
In the failure record summary, the time of occurrence, scope of impact, response details, and unresolved issues are compared with the original record.
Factory/manufacturing/logistics usage examples
In factories, AI can be used for demand forecasting, visual inspections, anomaly detection, and maintenance record searches, but human approval is required for safety-related shutdown and shipping decisions.
When using AI in manufacturing and logistics, data acquisition conditions and equipment/site constraints affect the results. The on-site manager makes the final decision by checking the shooting conditions for image inspection, the sensor status for abnormality detection, and the constraint conditions and performance for delivery planning.
| Applications | Requirements | Human Responsibilities | Main Challenges |
|---|---|---|---|
| Demand/Inventory Forecast | History and Variation Factors | Deciding on Order Quantity | Sudden Environmental Changes |
| Appearance inspection | Appropriate image data | Approval of shipment | Differences in shooting conditions |
| Abnormality detection | Equipment sensors | Stop and restart decisions | False alarms, missed |
| Maintenance search/procedure manual | Updated documents | Confirmation of safety standards | Mix of old records |
| Delivery plan | Constraints and results | Finalization of plan | Cooperation with existing equipment |
-
For demand/inventory forecasting, appoint a person to review forecast values when sudden environmental changes occur.
-
For visual inspection, check the inspection results when the shooting conditions change.
-
Notifications of abnormality detection are treated as information for starting on-site confirmation, not as a decision to stop or restart.
-
Updated documents are given priority in maintenance searches and procedure manuals, and safety standards are checked by the person in charge.
How to choose the work to streamline first
Introducing AI will be easier to verify if you start with a single task that requires a large amount of work, has few exceptions, has less impact even if errors occur, and can be compared with the same KPIs before and after the introduction.
-
List candidate operations by process.
-
Score expected effects, risks, and implementation difficulty.
-
Choose one task with high frequency and low risk.
-
Check gate conditions for legal and safety risks.
-
Conduct PoC with limited users and data.
Business selection score evaluated out of 100 points
It is easier to compare AI implementation candidates by scoring them not only on expected effects, but also on regularity, exception rate, data quality, risk, collaboration difficulty, and measurability in the same table.
| Evaluation items | Scoring | Conditions for high scores |
|---|---|---|
| Working hours | 15 | Total working hours are large |
| Frequency | 10 | Occurs continuously |
| Standardized level | 15 | Procedures and correct answers are clear |
| Exception rate | 10 | Few exceptions |
| Data Quality | 15 | Accurate and Authorized |
| Risk | 15 | Low impact of error |
| Cooperation difficulty level | 10 | Can be tried in existing environment |
| Measurable effect | 10 | Can be compared using the same KPI |
| Total | 100 | Relative comparison between candidates |
If there is a high legal, safety, or critical personal information risk, we will lower the priority even if it has a high score.
Criteria for determining tasks that should not be automated
For tasks with high legal implications, too many exceptions, undefinable correct answers, insufficient data, and unclear approval responsibilities, a design that supports human decision-making is more appropriate than full automation.
-
If there is a significant legal or safety impact, we will limit ourselves to presenting candidates.
-
If there are many exceptions, narrow down the target pattern.
-
If you cannot define the correct answer, leave it to them to organize the information.
-
If data is insufficient, collect and maintain it first.
-
If you are not sure who is responsible for approval, decide who will be responsible and then try again.
How to choose AI tools and implementation costs
Select an AI tool that suits the business problem you want to solve, whether it can be linked with existing systems, data handling, and operational structure, and compare the installation costs based on the annual total cost of ownership. It is important to not just decide on the license fee, but to include everything from initial setup, education, auditing, maintenance, and re-evaluation in the same quote.
The cost-effectiveness of AI implementation is determined not by the monthly fee, but by comparing the total annual ownership cost, including the settings, collaboration, training, auditing, and maintenance required after implementation, and the amount of work that can be reduced.
Selecting an AI tool means organizing the functions and management requirements necessary for the target business, comparing the cost and burden required for introduction and operation, and deciding on the method of introduction.
The cost structure changes depending on the number of users, target process, and whether there is individual development. Compare expected benefits, operator workload, and total annual cost of ownership rather than a single price list.
-
If you want to try it in a short period of time: Consider starting with the built-in AI of existing SaaS or general-purpose generated AI SaaS.
-
If you want to automate even routine screen operations: Consider linking with RPA.
-
If you want to have answers based on internal rules and procedure manuals: A candidate is RAG construction that can manage document authority.
-
If the requirements cannot be met with ready-made services: Add individual development to the comparison.
Selection criteria for SaaS, built-in AI, RPA collaboration, individual development, and RAG
If you want to try it out in a short period of time, the AI function of an existing SaaS, if you want to connect it to routine operations, then RPA integration is a good option, if you want to answer based on internal documents, then RAG is a good option, and if you have strong unique requirements, individual development is a good option. Narrow down the implementation method based on the scope of required customization and who will manage the data and authority.
If the business requirements can be met with existing SaaS, it is effective to first check the suitability of existing functions, as it is easier to reduce the burden of configuration, integration, and maintenance than individual development.
| Method | Introduction speed | Customization | Cooperation difficulty | Data management | Operational load | Suitable tasks/conditions |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Built-in AI in existing SaaS | Fast | Low | Low | Check contract terms | Low | If you want to start summarizing, drafting, and searching support within the business tools you are already using |
| General-purpose generation AI SaaS | Fast | Medium | Low to medium | Check corporate settings | Low to medium | When you want to support intellectual tasks common to multiple departments, such as writing, summarizing, and analysis |
| RPA collaboration | Medium | Medium | Medium | Manage execution authority | Medium | If you want to connect routine operations that can be set as rules, such as input, posting, and form processing |
| RAG construction | Medium | High | Medium to high | Inherit document authority | Medium to high | If you want to have answers based on internal regulations, procedure manuals, product materials, etc. |
| Individual development | Slow | Expensive | Expensive | Unique design | Expensive | If there are business requirements, screens, or approval flows that cannot be met with existing products |
For small and medium-sized enterprises, it is practical to try out the functions of the business suites they are already using, check the target business, input data, and user reactions, and then expand to collaboration and RAG. Rather than assuming company-wide deployment or individual development from the beginning, we choose processes that are easy to confirm effects.
-
Focus on one task and organize the flow from start to completion.
-
Check whether the information you are entering includes personal, customer, or confidential information.
-
Try to see if the standard features of your existing SaaS can meet your requirements.
-
If you need to post or execute operations to other systems, consider RPA or API linkage.
-
If it is necessary to refer to internal documents, determine how to update documents, access rights, and confirm the basis for answers.
-
Compare estimates for individual development only when requirements cannot be met with standard functions or integration.
Items that make up the installation cost and how to estimate it
Estimates for AI implementation include initial costs and monthly fees, as well as data maintenance, system integration, employee training, log auditing, maintenance, and revalidation when updating models. For each expense item, you can separate the expenses that occur only for the first time and the expenses that occur on an ongoing basis to clarify the budget and operational responsibility.
When introducing AI that involves API integration, RPA execution, and in-house data reference, the total cost of actual operation cannot be accurately compared unless the costs of permission settings, log auditing, maintenance, and re-verification are considered in addition to license costs.
| Cost items | Contents to include in the estimate | Points to check |
|---|---|---|
| Initial settings/PoC | Setting up the usage environment, verifying the target business, and creating initial rules | Who makes the settings and who approves the verification results |
| License/usage amount | Number of users, usage plan, API usage, processing amount | Costs when the number of users increases or decreases or usage amount changes |
| Collaborative development | API, RPA, authentication, data linkage with existing systems | Scope of modifications that occur when changing the linkage destination |
| Data maintenance | Collection, formatting, updating, access rights, document classification | Person in charge of data updates and procedures for deleting unnecessary data |
| Education and retention support | Training, manuals, response to inquiries, and dissemination of usage rules | Educational content for users, administrators, and approvers |
| Monitoring/Audit/Maintenance | Log confirmation, authority review, troubleshooting, inquiry response | Confirmation frequency, person in charge, contact route in case of a problem |
| Re-evaluation | Verification after model changes, checking output quality, updating business rules | Change conditions and approval procedures that require re-evaluation |
-
Estimate initial setup and PoC costs.
-
Calculate the license according to the number of people and usage amount.
-
Add collaborative development costs such as API and RPA.
-
Include data collection, formatting, and permission settings.
-
Account for training, manuals, and inquiries.
-
Add monitoring, log auditing, and maintenance costs.
-
Estimate the re-evaluation man-hours after changing the model.
-
Separate initial costs and ongoing costs and summarize them in a form that allows you to compare the work reduction effects.
Free tools also check terms of use, audit logs, administrator features, and support for input data. Even if it is free, if the management functions and data usage conditions do not meet the requirements, you will need to decide to remove it from the list of candidates for corporate use.
Comparison criteria for typical generative AI services
Generation AI for corporations compares not only generation performance, but also collaboration with existing tools, data usage conditions, SSO, permissions, audit logs, storage locations, and administrator functions based on fixed criteria. When making comparisons, apply the same business scenario and the same check items to each service and keep a record of your pre-contract decisions.
When selecting a generation AI for corporations, even if the answer quality is the same, services that do not comply with existing authentication, authority, and audit operations will increase the management burden, so it is necessary to evaluate functions and management requirements separately.
| Service candidates | Text generation | Business tool collaboration | Contract confirmation items | Operational items to confirm before implementation |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| ChatGPT | Draft, summary, analysis | Check by usage environment | Data usage, SSO, logs, storage location | Administrator settings, user authority range, input rules |
| Google Gemini | Draft, summarize, analyze | Check compatibility with Google environment | Permissions, management functions, storage conditions | Compatibility with existing sharing settings, administrator confirmation steps |
| Microsoft 365 Copilot | Documents, meetings, business support | Confirm compatibility with Microsoft environment | Existing permissions, logs, management settings | Scope of reference with existing permissions, audit procedures |
| Claude | Draft, summary, analysis | Check for each usage environment | Data usage, SSO, storage conditions | Administrator functions, usage logs, compliance with internal rules |
-
If you are mainly operating in an existing Google environment: Check the compatibility of permissions, storage, and management functions with the Google environment.
-
If the operation is based on an existing Microsoft environment: Check for consistency with existing permissions, logs, and management settings in the Microsoft environment.
-
If you are using multiple business tools: Check SSO, user management, data storage destination, API, and collaboration functions side by side.
-
When handling highly confidential information: Check the terms of use, storage conditions, audit logs, and permission settings for input data before signing a contract.
Functions, fees, and contract terms are confirmed with official information at the time of introduction, and the confirmation date is recorded in the comparison record. Prices, provided features, and terms of use are subject to change, so it is important not to equate the information at the time of verification with the information at the time of contract.
How to improve AI business efficiency | 7 steps to implement
AI implementation will proceed in 7 steps: goal setting, business visualization, data confirmation, means selection, PoC, deployment and education, effect measurement and improvement.
-
Set objectives and business KPIs.
-
Visualize the current flow and select the target process.
-
Check data quality, permissions, and terms of use.
-
Decide on AI methods and responsibilities that suit the process.
-
Measure effectiveness and risk with a limited scope PoC.
-
Educate, standardize, and roll out in stages.
-
Monitor KPIs and reevaluate them when they change.
Steps 1 to 3 | Define the issue, target business, and data
At the initial stage of AI implementation, before selecting tools, define the business KPIs to be improved, target processes, usage data, and the person responsible for checking.
-
Write the purpose, KPI, and responsible person in the KPI definition document.
-
Create a business flow diagram from input to approval.
-
Organize data list, authority, quality, and risk hypothesis.
| Stage | Deliverable | Cause of failure | Completion judgment |
|---|---|---|---|
| Objective setting | KPI definition document | Objective becomes “AI introduction” | Values before introduction can be measured |
| Process selection | Work flow diagram | Scope is too broad | Targets and exceptions are clear |
| Data confirmation | Data list, risk hypothesis | Authority and quality not confirmed | Terms of use approved |
Reason: According to a RIETI survey, 5.8% of workers use AI in their work, and the efficiency of work using AI improved by an average of 21.8%, but the overall productivity improvement effect was estimated to be about 1.2%.
Steps 4-5|Choose a method and verify it with PoC
What you should check in PoC is not whether the AI works, but whether the existing business KPIs can be improved with acceptable risk and confirmation burden.
-
Choose a method from generation AI, RPA, AI-OCR, RAG, etc.
-
Limit users, period, data, and number of targets.
-
Measure the same target and conditions before and after introduction.
-
Record quality, confirmation time, number of exceptions, and operational load.
-
Judgment will be made based on the criteria of continuation, modification, and discontinuation.
If there is insufficient data, go back to collecting, and if there are too many exceptions, narrow down the target. If usage is not established, we will revise business conduct and training.
Basic form of generated AI business efficiency prompt
Business prompts will be easier to reuse if you fix the role, purpose, input, reference range, prohibitions, output format, and items for human confirmation.
-
Role: Specify "You are responsible for organizing sales records."
-
Purpose: Specify the creation of a summary for CRM registration, etc.
-
Input: Separate and pass the minutes and inquiry text.
-
Reference range: Limited to input text and specified materials only.
-
Prohibitions: Speculation, unconfirmed numbers, and supplementing with confidential information are prohibited.
-
Output format: Fix item name, number of characters, table format, etc.
-
Confirmation items: List proper nouns, numerical values, grounds, and external expressions.
For commercial emails, the sender approves. The meeting minutes are checked against the original text, and the person in charge checks the inquiry classification for misclassification.
Steps 6-7 | Deployment, education, and continuous improvement
To establish AI, incorporate standard templates, education, contact points, usage logs, and re-evaluation when changing models into operations.
-
Gradually expand target departments and users.
-
Provide training on prohibited information and approval procedures.
-
Version-control validated prompts.
-
Establish a point of contact for inquiries and exception handling.
-
Monitor utilization, retention, and quality KPIs.
-
Re-evaluate when business rules or models change.
How to measure effectiveness and calculate ROI
AI ROI is evaluated by converting the time saved into monetary value, adding the reduction in rework costs and outsourcing costs, and subtracting the annual cost.
Align the number of subjects, subjects, measurement period, and calculation conditions. Estimated values and actual values are clearly separated and managed.
Rationale: The Bank of Japan points out that the impact of AI on productivity largely depends on the scope of tasks to which AI is applied and the speed of its adoption, and that there is currently a high degree of uncertainty regarding its quantitative effects on the macro economy.
ROI and Payback Period Calculation Formula
The annual benefit is the sum of the value of time saved and the cost saved on a yearly basis. It is distinctive in that it distinguishes between estimation and actual measurement.
Annual effect amount = time saved x hourly unit price + reduced outsourcing costs and rework costs
ROI = (annual effect amount - annual cost) ÷ annual cost x 100
The payback period is determined by dividing the initial investment by the monthly net benefits.
| Input item | Input value | Calculation purpose |
|---|---|---|
| Number of cases processed per month | Enter actual value | Monthly time reduction |
| Time saved per case | Enter the difference before and after | Total time saved |
| Hourly rate | Enter internal standards | Time effect amount |
| Initial cost | Enter estimated amount | Payback period |
| Monthly costs | Includes operating costs | Annual costs |
| Reducing outsourcing and rework | Enter the actual amount | Annual effect amount |
KPIs to track other than time
The effectiveness of AI implementation is measured not only in processing time, but also in terms of errors, remands, response speed, usage retention, human confirmation time, and business KPIs for reallocation destinations.
| KPI classification | Indicator examples | Contents to be evaluated |
|---|---|---|
| Productivity | Number of cases processed, lead time | Processing capacity |
| Quality | Error and Rebound Rates | Accuracy and Rework |
| Customer response | Response time, first resolution rate | Service quality |
| Confirmation load | Human confirmation time, number of exceptions | Hidden operational man-hours |
| Establishment | Usage rate, continuous use, reuse rate | Practicality on site |
| Reallocation results | Number of proposals, training implementation, quality improvement | Business value of surplus capacity |
Primary example|Comparing before and after PoC under the same conditions
Reproducibility can be determined in the primary example of AI by showing the target business, measurement period, number of cases processed, time before and after introduction, quality, and human confirmation time under the same conditions.
| Recorded items | Recorded contents |
|---|---|
| Business details | Pre-implementation flow from input to approval |
| Scope | Number of people, period, number of cases processed |
| Usage configuration | AI, RPA, RAG, approval process |
| Time | Actual measured time before and after introduction and calculation method |
| Quality | Errors, Reverts, Missing |
| Check load | Locations and times checked by people |
| Correction process | Dealing with data shortages, exceptions, and poor retention |
| Remaining issues | Operational load, cost, unhandled exceptions |
By saving screen recordings, prompt versions, and evaluation data, you can revalidate under the same conditions after making changes.
Points to note | AI governance and security
When introducing AI, it is necessary to decide on the information that can be input, permission tools, output confirmation, access privileges, log storage, and reporting routes in the event of an accident before the introduction.
-
Establish conditions for entering confidential and personal information.
-
Check the basis assuming hallucination.
-
Check the copyright and production terms of use.
-
Limit authority to the scope necessary for business.
-
Prepare audit logs and shadow AI countermeasures.
-
Set usage and cost limits.
AI usage policy created on one page
Practical AI usage policy includes prohibited input information, permission tools, person responsible for confirmation, log storage, exception requests, and reporting routes in the event of an accident.
-
Define the prohibited input information along with specific examples.
-
Specify available tools and accounts.
-
Define facts, figures, and copyright confirmation items.
-
Decide who will be responsible for approval before sending externally.
-
Define the target of logs, retention period, and viewing privileges.
-
Establish a departmental exception request and approval pathway.
-
Specify contact information and initial response procedures in the event of an accident.
Measures against hallucination, personal information, and copyright
Since the output of generated AI does not guarantee factuality, we will incorporate basis confirmation, conditions for handling personal information, similarity to existing works, and approval before external use into the business process.
Using RAGs also requires accuracy and update management of reference documents. Please refer your answer to the source and check it against the original text.
Before inputting personal or confidential information to an external AI, check the contract terms, learning usage, storage location, and administrator settings. The product will also be checked for similarity to existing copyrighted works and the terms of use.
AI Agent Least Privilege and Approval Gate
Give AI agents minimal privileges and have human approval steps before sending, paying, deleting, or updating sensitive data.
-
Separate view, create, update, and delete permissions.
-
Payment and external transmission will be made after approval.
-
Set limits on the number of processing items, amount, and execution time.
-
Log input, judgment, and operation results.
-
Have emergency shutdown and rollback procedures in place.
-
When an exception occurs, the process is stopped and handed over to someone else.
Management items to prevent operational debt after implementation
After implementing AI, manage prompts, models, evaluation results, exception handling, execution logs, and clarify re-evaluation conditions and stopping criteria for changes.
| Management items | Contents to be left in the ledger | Review conditions |
|---|---|---|
| Prompt | Version, Author, Approver | When changing business rules |
| Evaluation data | Input, expected result, judgment | When a new exception occurs |
| Model | Name, settings, date of change | When updating the model |
| Log | Execution, approval, errors | Regular audit, when an accident occurs |
| Exception handling | Cause, response, and prevention of recurrence | When the number of cases increases |
| Stopping criteria | Quality deterioration, cost overruns, accidents | When criteria are reached |
| Decommissioning decision | Utilization rate, effectiveness, maintenance load | If the benefits do not continue |
Internal link to read next
Once the target operations have been decided, we will flesh out the areas that were found to be lacking during the PoC, including user education, system integration, internal data search, and governance.
- How to proceed with business improvement: Reduce rework and waiting time before automating.
- How to start business automation: Design input, execution conditions, and stopping in case of exceptions in one job.
- Business automation using AI: Uses AI for classification and drafting, leaving human confirmation.
- AI training for presidents: Managers themselves can try it out in their own work.
- Procedure for corporate introduction of Grok Bot: Organize work, collaboration partners, approvals, and operations.
Source/Reference materials
-
AI usage and productivity of Japanese companies and workers
https://www.rieti.go.jp/jp/publications/rd/149.html (Acquisition date 2026-10-25) -
JIPDEC and ITR announce the results of "Corporate IT Utilization Trend Survey 2025"
https://www.jipdec.or.jp/news/pressrelease/20250314.html (Acquisition date 2026-10-25) -
Announcement of “Survey on the actual situation regarding generative AI and how it works”
https://rc.persol-group.co.jp/news/release-20260203-1000-1/ (Acquired on 2026-10-25) -
Impact of AI introduction on productivity: Conceptual organization and international comparison
https://www.boj.or.jp/research/wps_rev/rev_2025/rev25j10.htm (Acquisition date 2026-10-25)